As international competition and global temperatures continue to rise, many turn to the Arctic as the next piece of land for trade opportunities. However, the land within the Arctic is stuck between a multitude of claims from across the globe.
Unlike Antarctica, the greater Arctic has never had an official neutrality agreement signed into international law. Instead, the eight arctic states on the Arctic Council — Canada, the United States (via Alaska), Norway, Sweden, Finland, Iceland, Denmark and Russia — hold each other in a stalemate of sorts. Since each nation has claims to different parts of the Arctic region, no country dares to attempt a full invasion for fear of retribution. The stalemate, because of this, keeps the Arctic region stable.
“Competition in the region is further fuelled by another structural transformation: climate change,” Pier Paolo Ramondi, a professor at the Catholic University of Sacred Heart in Milan, wrote in his article for 360 Info. “Melting ice is creating new security challenges but also economic opportunities, from resource extraction to the development of shipping routes, inevitably attracting the interest of Arctic and non-Arctic states alike.”
As the ice melts, both the Arctic and the rest of the world are impacted. There are over 4 million people who call the Arctic home, with around 500,000 of them being from indigenous communities, with the largest percentage of indigenous peoples being located in Canada.
Presently, the two most pressing issues for these indigenous populations are rising sea levels and melting permafrost — both of which destabilize their land.
As defined by NASA, Permafrost is “any ground that remains completely frozen — 32°F (0°C) or colder — for at least two years straight.” When permafrost melts, it adds water to the oceans, therefore causing sea levels to rise. These challenges also endanger indigenous populations’ access to freshwater, with climate-induced changes on land surfaces dramatically impacting the availability of water.
Dr. Chelsea Koch, a marine scientist with a focus on Arctic ecosystems and an assistant professor at American University, has similar concerns. For many coastal communities in western and northern Alaska, the loss of reliable sea ice poses a direct threat to safety and food security, she said.
Another danger to the environment is icebreakers, or ships with reinforced hulls designed to maneuver through polar regions. Between 2013 and 2023, Arctic shipping increased nearly 40 percent. This is increasingly possible due to the Northern Sea Route, which greatly reduces shipping time between Europe and Asia. Although the route is only normally accessible in the warmer months, the World Economic Forum has said that with warming climates causing retreating polar ice, the route could become accessible for extended periods.
Despite the warming, it is likely that these shipping vessels will need to be accompanied by icebreakers to prevent any accidents in icier waters, continuing the negative environmental effects.
Russia’s increased militarization in recent years has also put strain on the Arctic. According to the U.S. Naval Institute, the Arctic is critical to Russia’s gas industry and economic development. Therefore, Russia has worked to re-establish old Soviet military bases in the region, along with creating new infrastructure for its own economic gain.
Russia’s position as a gas producer is also cause for concern, since the Arctic is projected to hold 13 percent of the globe’s untapped oil and 30 percent of its undiscovered natural gas reserves. Should this estimate be true, the Arctic would pass Saudi Arabia for the second most oil reserves.
Despite Russia’s increase in militarization in the region, its conflict with Ukraine has slowed its emphasis on the Arctic. With western sanctions being put on the nation in February 2022 following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Russia has had a harder time building more infrastructure in the region. Furthermore, several western developments have led Russia away from the Arctic, instead turning closer to Asia.
Sparked by Finland joining NATO in April 2023 and Sweden joining the alliance in March 2024, Russia has created an even tighter relationship with China. However, Russian goals have not turned away from the Arctic entirely, with the expansion of NATO also spurring Russia to move more of its military to the north.
Similarly, the Trump administration’s aggressive nature on the issue of the Arctic has left many wondering about the neutrality of the region.
Koch also mentioned that “[Her] concern is that the administration’s emphasis on territorial control and strategic competition can undermine the trust needed for Arctic cooperation.”
“President Trump’s statements about acquiring Greenland have strained relationships with allies and raised fundamental questions about sovereignty and Greenlanders’ right to determine their own future,” Koch said.
Arctic tensions leave many questions up in the air, with nations around the world caught between the uncertainty of both Putin and Trump’s next moves. These increased tensions have left indigenous populations caught in the crossfire, as both the United States and Russia turn their focus towards the military and economic issues in the Arctic, rather than the environmental dangers that continue to devastate communities around the world.
This article was edited by Caroline Shinney, Jessica Ackerman and Gabrielle McNamee. Copy editing by Avery Grossman and Ryan Sieve. Fact-checking done by Josie Burnette.



